Crossroads and Cross-purposes Exploring the scope of hope amid all hopelessness

Some hard thinking is required.  Each one of us has to do it. In fact, every one owes it. I owe it as a kibitz columnist and leaders owe as men who lead and shape the destiny of people.

Sitting in one-day seminar organized by the Kashmir Bar Association on Tuesday on the subject, “Kashmir Freedom Struggle in the Current Global Political Scenario and Prospects of A Solution” and listening to learned speakers, I started pondering: Where have we erred during the past sixty four years?  Are we as the people responsible for the perpetuation of the uncertainties that have been consuming us within like some deadly diseases? Have    leaders failed us.  Are we paying for their amateurish approach, failing to rise to the occasions, and taking right decisions at the right moment?  If investing in one leader and one party has done wrong after wrong to us and led us from a murky pond into   marshy one. Alternatively, was the idea of collective leadership and the ‘forum politics’ right answers for correcting the past mistakes? If the mistakes committed in the past are not being repeated.

I heard speaker after speaker filling the air with despair, disappointment and nothing but pessimism. Some speakers called for incremental approach instead of the holistic one that has been the refrain of a larger section of the lawyers’ fraternity for past many years. Some streaks of hope were discernable in the speech of a law teacher from the University of Kashmir. His optimism emanated from the changed geo-strategic scenario in the region. It would be too early to comment on the post 2014 scenario when USA is expected to completely withdraw its troops from Afghanistan. The emerging scenario that indicates tilting of power balance in the region with Iran, Pakistan and Afghanistan likely entering into a strategic partnership has a couple of caveats like, if China joins such a strategic partnership.  Moreover, if subservience of Iran and India relations   to the India-US- Israel strategic partnership increases as the date for withdrawal approaches.  It is a wait and watch situation- in this wait and watch where does Kashmir stand is a big question. In this wait and watch situation if Kashmir leadership is not again caught on a wrong foot that will lead into yet another cul-de-sac.    

Caught up in the web of questions, believing that history is the best guide, I started filliping through the pages of history. That opened up like a bible revealing causes of our predicaments and their perpetuation. 

Six decades narrative of this land is tormented with leadership working at  cross purposes at the cross roads of our  history. It in fact has been this working at the cross-purposes at the critical junctures that I see as one of the fundamental contributory factors   the messy situation Kashmir is caught up in.  That has steered us from one uncertainty to another and continues to do so even as on the date. To illustrate my point of view let me cull out a few glaring incidents from the pages of our history that I believe have contributed to the birth and continuation of Kashmir agonies:

o Barely one year after its birth in 1932, the Jammu and Kashmir Muslim Conference got divide more out of the machinations of Maharaja Hari Singh, than any inherent contradictions in the leadership. Had then leadership heeded to the advice of Allama Iqbal and ended their differences the fifth columnists like Bazaz would not have succeeded in misdirecting the movement. This division snowballed into a disastrous situation and caused what historian Alistair Lamb called as “birth of a tragedy”. And what happened later could be best described as after effects of an earthquake.

o In 1964, after the Holy Relic Movement the goal was not only distinctly visible but a step away. Had  the then leadership set a higher goal than settling scores with 1953 bête noire and allowing the ‘hidden hands’ a greater space to operate for inducting their trusted into corridors of power for eroding Article 370 further  in exchange release of some leaders perhaps this impasse would not have been there at all. It was this maturely amateurish handling of the movement, which revived old political feuds and added yet another ugly chapter to our history, thus distanced the goal further.
o In the post 1971 and 1972 situation, the Kashmir leadership not only failed to grapple with the new situation but also was terrifyingly afflicted with ‘hamlet syndrome’ that entrapped it into a bargaining game for entering into the corridors of power.   Had not two of the three organizations demanding plebiscite   been won over by Syed Mir Qasim the then Chief Minister and made them to agree to partake in elections to exhaust bargaining power of the Plebiscite Front that had boycotted the 1972 election, perhaps the Front would have never become bold enough to enter into an agreement with New Delhi in 1975.
o The Indira-Sheikh Accord would have ab initio crumbled had the   not wind been taken out of the sails other parties by not arriving at an arrangement with them during 1972 elections. Intriguingly, these organizations endorsed the 1975 accord by jumping on to the Janata bandwagon directly and indirectly and allowing the National Conference an unprecedented victory at the hustings. This was good as writing an epitaph on the movement for bringing permanent peace in the region.
      These are few illustrations, the post 1977 history is replete with instances that suggest,  those sitting in the cockpits have at many a critical junctures by  working at cross-purposes defeated  the movements that held promise of ending uncertainties in the state. Many a time, history offered opportunities to men in cockpits to steer out of whirlwinds but for their unskilled approach blustered with egocentricity they failed the opportunities were lost.
History has brought us at yet another critical juncture and if leadership at this time also works at cross-purposes and does not understand nuances of the emerging scenario in the sub-continent vis-à-vis Kashmir it would be writing yet another tragic chapter in the history of the land… Introspection is need of the hour.
(Mail at